第一篇：英語辯論會總結(jié)

自動化093、094班 英語辯論賽總結(jié) 組織者:尚國偉

郭楠 時間：2012年3月27日 地點：主校區(qū) 二教 人數(shù)：22人 辯手：6人 群眾辯手:16人 主持人：尚國偉 郭楠

主題：一個人的成功是先天條件重要還是后天重要 正反方：本次辯論賽由我班和自動化094班共同完成 正方成員：尚國偉 池榮光 馬穎 劉世杰 觀點：一個人的成功是先天條件重要 反方成員：郭楠 瞿鶴 朱玉鑫 喬志強 觀點：一個人的成功是先天條件重要

辯論賽流程：1.主持人宣布辯論賽主題，介紹參賽成員。

2.主持人講解辯論規(guī)則并宣布辯論賽開始。

3．第一環(huán)節(jié)，由正方一辯開始到四辯輪流陳述觀點，再由反方一辯到四辯陳述觀點 第二環(huán)節(jié)，自由辯論，由正方一辯開始提出問題，雙方進入自由辯論環(huán)節(jié) 5 第三環(huán)節(jié)，群眾辯論，同學(xué)分別表達自己所支持的觀點.5 第四環(huán)節(jié)，雙方由一辯總結(jié)、陳述觀點 第五環(huán)節(jié)，群眾辯論，同學(xué)分別表達自己所支持的觀點.最后一個環(huán)節(jié)，評委點評，并結(jié)合群眾觀點，選出最佳團隊

與會的同學(xué)感受：大家普遍感覺，進入大三后，班級的活動組織起來變得很困難了。比如在一些假期，大部分同學(xué)都有自己的事情，所以班級活動在很多況下都不能全員出席。所以，這次組織辯論會也是大家聚在一起說說心里話很難得的機會。另外，由于大三沒有了英語課，大家在學(xué)習(xí)英語上的機會就少了很多，于是，這次英語辯論會的開展對于提高英語學(xué)習(xí)的熱情還是有很大的幫助的。通過這次英語辯論會，大家還學(xué)到了一些英語的表述技巧和學(xué)習(xí)方法，對于那些英語還沒有過四級以及想要超越六級的同學(xué)起到了很好的引導(dǎo)作用。

參賽辯手感言： 大家感覺，由于種種原因這次的英語辯論會的開展有些匆忙，大家的準(zhǔn)備組織者感言：情況不是很好，總是會遇到一些很常用的單詞卻不知道意思的情況基于這種情況，大家認為雖然大三的時間很緊張，類似的活動還是可以繼續(xù)開展的，這樣不僅會給緊張的大三生活帶來一些歡樂，也可以鞭策大家繼續(xù)學(xué)習(xí)英語，用好英語，同時時也練習(xí)了英語口語和語言表達能力以及發(fā)言的邏輯思維。他們也表示通過參加辯論會，他們發(fā)現(xiàn)比沒參加時收獲的確很大，還感受到一種將英語真實的運用的快感和成就感。另外有些同學(xué)也借這次活動提了一些意見。比如，學(xué)校的陽光英語活動正在逐漸的減少，參與人數(shù)也在遞減，現(xiàn)在很少能夠看到有同學(xué)在早上讀英語。他們都認為，陽光英語是一個很好的活動，是大家交流英語學(xué)習(xí)方法和技巧的良好平臺，也是增加學(xué)習(xí)興趣的法寶，所以大家普遍認為這種活動應(yīng)該多多開展，對于同學(xué)們的英語學(xué)習(xí)一定有很多好處?？偠灾蠹彝ㄟ^這次辯論賽發(fā)現(xiàn)了自己英語學(xué)習(xí)中的短板，比如說口語能力，這促使他們更加積極的參與到英語的學(xué)習(xí)中。同時重拾了學(xué)習(xí)英語的興趣，緩解了學(xué)習(xí)的壓力。幾乎所有人都表示，通過這次英語辯論會，大家收獲頗豐，是一個有意義的活動。

這已經(jīng)是我都四次組織英語辯論會了，這次辯論會也是大學(xué)器件的最后一次了，即收官之作。雖然由于許多同學(xué)在大三的時候私人事務(wù)比較多，致使這次辯論會的組織困難重重，但經(jīng)過班委的努力，大家還是聚在了一起開了一次成功的辯論會?？偟膩碚f，在總結(jié)前幾次辯論會的不足的基礎(chǔ)上，這次的比賽較前兩次相對較成熟了一些，但依舊存在著一些問題。主要的問題就是大家的時間不好統(tǒng)一，這也是英語辯論賽組織的最主要困難。另外一方面，大家基本上都在忙于從事本專業(yè)相關(guān)領(lǐng)域的研究，所以對于英語的學(xué)習(xí)放松了很多，這也是本次英語辯論賽旨在解決的問題。從英語辯論賽的效果上來說，大家對于英語的學(xué)習(xí)重視度又重新的回到了正常的水平。另一方面，這次英語辯論賽得到了友班的大力支持，總體氛圍十分融洽。這不僅是一場為英語學(xué)習(xí)打造的平臺也是增進兩班友誼的大好機會。在一方面，這次英語辯論賽的總結(jié)更加的鍛煉了我作為一名學(xué)委調(diào)度大家 參與活動的能力?？偟膩碚f，經(jīng)過本次英語辯論賽，從前期的準(zhǔn)備工作到賽場上的辯論，以及賽后的總結(jié)，都讓同學(xué)們重拾了英語學(xué)習(xí)的動力，增進了班級的互動與友誼。辯手們的整體準(zhǔn)備都很充分，但由于長時間不學(xué)習(xí)英語都有一些疏忽。借此機會也給他們敲響了英語不學(xué)則退的警鐘，督促他們學(xué)習(xí)。總而言之這是一次比較成功的英語辯論賽

自動化093班

尚國偉

第二篇：辯論會總結(jié)

為幫助青年學(xué)生正確認知社會主義核心價值觀的戰(zhàn)略意義和深刻內(nèi)涵，引導(dǎo)青年學(xué)生樹立正確的價值觀，我班特舉辦了“青春引航之價值觀”的主題班會，并針對我們即將面臨的職業(yè)選擇問題，舉辦了“我的職場價值觀”的自主辯論會，主要討論我們對于各種職業(yè)的主觀評價，從而確定以后的發(fā)展方向。

辯論會分為正反兩方，分別闡述他們更加傾向的職業(yè)。由于本專業(yè)是信息管理類，很多同學(xué)選擇拓展所學(xué)，從事與此相關(guān)的高科技類工作。然而，作為對立的一方，有的人更傾向于服務(wù)類工作，希望將來能服務(wù)大眾。

正方表示，從事高科技類工作可以為我們帶來更大收益，更能贏得人的羨慕和欽佩，生活質(zhì)量和生活水平也會高于那些從事服務(wù)業(yè)的。反方則表示高科技類工作長期接收各種輻射，工作緊張，生活壓抑，沒有從事服務(wù)業(yè)的人生活得幸福和有歸屬感。雙方都列舉了一系列的事例作為論據(jù)，讓本次辯論會充實而精彩。最重要的是，幾乎每個同學(xué)都對未來充滿希望，定下了自己努力的目標(biāo)和方向，充分體現(xiàn)了他們的價值觀：愛國，敬業(yè)，誠信，友善。

本次活動的圓滿完成，為我們下一次開展活動積累了寶貴的經(jīng)驗。

第三篇：辯論會活動總結(jié)

活動總結(jié)

一、活動背景

為加強我們當(dāng)代大學(xué)生對科技的認識、了解科技對生活多方面的影響，由美術(shù)與藝術(shù)學(xué)院團總支學(xué)生會主辦，科技部、督導(dǎo)部承辦了以“科技與生活”為主題的辯論會；于2010年11月1日和2日分別在三教602教室、504教室進行了初賽；于2010年11月4日在三教508教室進行了復(fù)賽和決賽。

二、活動目的為豐富我們的大學(xué)生活，加強全體學(xué)生對于科技與生活關(guān)系的認識，提高科學(xué)技術(shù)的宣傳力度，同時為具有一定語言表述能力和辯論能力的同學(xué)提供表現(xiàn)的舞臺。

三、活動準(zhǔn)備

1、擬定活動計劃、申請批準(zhǔn)活動；

2、申請活動經(jīng)費、拉活動贊助金；

3、購買活動獎品、獎狀；

4、申請教室、做活動宣傳；

5、分比賽隊、請評委、特邀嘉賓。

四、活動流程

（一）初賽

比賽隊有七個，有抽簽決定一個晉級隊和三對對決隊進行初賽，最終決出四隊晉級隊；

（二）復(fù)賽、決賽開幕式

（三）復(fù)賽

由四個晉級隊以抽簽的形式?jīng)Q定兩組對決隊，并確定場次；進行對決，決出勝者進入決賽，剩余兩隊按評分確定第三名；

（四）決賽

由決賽雙方進行比賽，按照評委評分確定冠軍、亞軍。

（五）頒獎

由三位評委分別為冠、亞、季軍頒發(fā)獎狀、獎品；并由評委致詞。

（六）比賽結(jié)束

評委、觀眾陸續(xù)退場。

五、活動成效與不足

活動整體情況較好，活動流程順暢；選手表現(xiàn)積極，辯論場面較為激烈；初步取得成效和預(yù)期目的，較好的宣傳了科技與生活的關(guān)系，使我們充分認識了科學(xué)技術(shù)的兩面性，明白作為21世紀的我們應(yīng)該學(xué)會掌控這把雙刃刀來造福社會、人類；但由于首次組織辯論賽，對辯論賽流程還不夠了解造成整個比賽流程有所疏漏，以及準(zhǔn)備時間不夠充足導(dǎo)致本次活動有所不足，賽后已作出思考、分析：

1.由于主持人對于主持辯論賽沒有經(jīng)驗，造成比賽流程有所疏漏；

第四篇：關(guān)于電腦的利與弊英語辯論會

Square one debate: Thank you!Fellow teachers，friends argue the other side, Hello, everyone!Mankind will enter the information age, network more and more strongly involved in our lives, more and more close to our students.Students online in the end is a big profit or harm greatly? Us believe: students online more good than harm.I will explain four aspects to our view:

正方一辯：謝謝主席！各位老師、同學(xué)、對方辯友，大家好！人類將步入信息時代，網(wǎng)絡(luò)越來越強烈地介入我們的生活，越來越貼近我們中學(xué)生。中學(xué)生上網(wǎng)到底是利大還是弊大呢？我方堅信：中學(xué)生上網(wǎng)利大于弊。我將從4個方面來闡述我方觀點： necessity.This is an era of knowledge economy, information is expanding at an unprecedented speed and explosion, the future of the world is a network of the world, to make our country in the world of information to keep pace, as the main force of the 21st century, we are bound to can quickly adapt to this high-tech society, we should have from the outside quickly, timely access to scientific information and effective capacity, with the ability to disseminate scientific information, which is the scientific quality.The Internet is precisely adapted to this requirement.Comrade Deng Xiaoping is not to say: “Computer to start with children.”

1.必要性。這是一個知識經(jīng)濟的時代，信息正在以前所未有的速度膨脹和爆炸，未來的世界是網(wǎng)絡(luò)的世界，要讓我國在這個信息世界中跟上時代的步伐，作為21世紀主力軍的我們，必然要能更快地適應(yīng)這個高科技的社會，要具有從外界迅速、及時獲取有效科學(xué)信息的能力，具有傳播科學(xué)信息的能力，這就是科學(xué)素質(zhì)。而因特網(wǎng)恰恰適應(yīng)了這個要求。鄧小平同志不是說：“計算機要從娃娃抓起”。(2)practicality.Network World resource sharing, it's like a cornucopia, an inexhaustible supply of “rich Gold Mountain”, who is eager to work hard in this gold mine, whoever would be obtained.You can learn from the fastest to find information, you can learn more knowledge outside the classroom, and flexible use of curricular knowledge, and promote the development of thinking, to develop the creativity of students.Internet also can transcend time and space and economic constraints, accept online elite education, have any questions you can always make a request via E-mail the teacher's guidance.And interactive learning on the Internet, rich 3D graphics display，language

interpretation

and

other multimedia content to make learning easier and fun, this is not possible with any textbook.2.實用性。網(wǎng)絡(luò)世界資源共享，它就像一個聚寶盆，一座取之不盡用之不竭的“富金山”，誰勤于在這座金山上耕耘勞動，誰就會有所得。你可以從中最快地查找學(xué)習(xí)資料，可以學(xué)會更多課堂外的知識，并靈活地運用課內(nèi)知識，促進思維的發(fā)展，培養(yǎng)中學(xué)生的創(chuàng)造力。上網(wǎng)還可以超越時空和經(jīng)濟的制約，在網(wǎng)上接受名校的教育，有什么問題，你也盡可以隨時通過E-mail請求老師的指導(dǎo)。而且互聯(lián)網(wǎng)上的交互式學(xué)習(xí)、豐富的三維圖形展示、語言解說等多媒體內(nèi)容，使得學(xué)習(xí)變得輕松、有趣，這是任何教科書都不可能具備的。reality.The dawn of the province is to rapidly advance engineering education information, primary and secondary schools in the province to establish the Internet every classroom, computer spread Internet knowledge to promote students home Internet access, remote education and knowledge sharing for the province to provide free primary and secondary school classes online students learn inside and outside the counseling and training in the application of information technology, interest and awareness, training students to acquire, analyze, process information.Look around us, straight out of the school's Web site is booming, Lin Shouhua secretary, Chen Xin teachers do not also suggest that you go to the school's website to see it? In section, the class page does not have the production in full swing it? Indeed, as a new thing, the network there are some drawbacks, but the students at the school of education under the school to strengthen young people's outlook on life, values education, students of right and wrong, beauty and ugliness, the ability to judge good and evil , shape and behavior of students good moral standards.Correct guidance of the teacher and parent's instructions, will enable us to apply a correct attitude to the network this tool.The 21st century is the computer network era, today's society in the future our students will serve as the pillars.Understanding and knowledge of computer networking knowledge, career in the future information age is the most powerful weapon.Let us believe that we pay a little bit of effort, the sand will eventually converge exchange tower, will eventually stand on the shoulders of giants.So, I once again state our point of view: students online more good than harm./ / 現(xiàn)實性。我省的曙光工程就是為了快速推進教育信息化，在我省每所中小學(xué)建立因特網(wǎng)教室，普及計算機因特網(wǎng)知識，推動中學(xué)生家庭上網(wǎng)，實現(xiàn)遠程教育與知識共享為全省中小學(xué)生提供免費的網(wǎng)上課內(nèi)外輔導(dǎo)培養(yǎng)中小學(xué)生學(xué)習(xí)和應(yīng)用信息、技術(shù)的興趣與意識，培養(yǎng)學(xué)生獲取、分析、處理信息的能力。再看看我們身邊，學(xué)校的網(wǎng)站不正搞的紅紅火火，林壽樺書記、陳欣老師不也建議大家去學(xué)校的網(wǎng)站看一看嗎？年段、班級的網(wǎng)頁不也都在緊鑼密鼓的制作嗎？ 的確，作為一種新生事物，網(wǎng)絡(luò)存在著一些弊端，但中學(xué)生處在學(xué)校的教育之下，學(xué)校要加強對青少年的人生觀、價值觀教育，培養(yǎng)學(xué)生對是非、美丑、善惡的判斷能力，塑造學(xué)生良好的道德和行為規(guī)范。在老師的正確引導(dǎo)和家長的指點下，必能使我們以一個正確的心態(tài)來應(yīng)用網(wǎng)絡(luò)這種工具。

21世紀將是計算機網(wǎng)絡(luò)時代，今日的莘莘學(xué)子將擔(dān)任未來社會的棟梁。了解和掌握計算機網(wǎng)絡(luò)知識，就是闖蕩未來信息時代的最強有力的武器。讓我們相信，我們今天所付出的一點一滴的努力，終將會聚沙匯塔，終將站在巨人的肩膀上。所以，我再一次陳述我方觀點：中學(xué)生上網(wǎng)利大于弊

Anti-side of a debate: Thank you!You judge teachers, students, and Hello, everyone!Friends talked to each other just argue about online education, but online education is a business, but nothing exaggerated hype.Not only in China, even in the U.S.magazine “USA Today” survey showed that: 86% of the surveyed teachers, librarians, and computer management believes that children using the Internet does not improve their classroom performance.對方辯友津津樂道地談網(wǎng)上教育，但網(wǎng)上教育不過是商家的夸大其詞的炒作罷了。不僅在中國，即使在美國權(quán)威雜志《今日美國》的調(diào)查表明：86%被調(diào)查的教師、圖書管理員以及電腦管理人員相信，孩子們使用因特網(wǎng)不會提高他們的課堂成績。

Friends of endless debate just the other side, is to give all of you show the network in a quick exchange of information and convenience.But I advise you not to smoke and mirrors for high school students can access, I would like to take the other pair of eye, see the pros and cons of the network clearly, plainly, so true.From the quantity that the current network has three difficult problems: the first is Internet security issues, mainly refers to hackers, viruses and online fraud;second category refers to the sex and violence and hatred spread of harmful information;third category is all kinds of information pollution and waste, Friends of impassioned debate in the other four-minute remarks, the world's main website has been hacked nearly 200 times, the global Internet computer virus may have been the latest 170 million times......the reality , the Internet has brought many students hazard:

交流方面的快捷性和方便性。但我奉勸您對中學(xué)生上網(wǎng)可不要霧里看花，我愿借對方一雙慧眼，把網(wǎng)絡(luò)的利弊看得清清楚楚、明明白白、真真切切。從量上說，目前網(wǎng)絡(luò)有三個難以解決的問題：第一類是網(wǎng)上安全問題，主要是指黑客、病毒和網(wǎng)上欺詐等；第二類是指傳播色情暴力和仇恨的不良信息；第三類是形形色色的信息污染和垃圾，就在對方辯友慷慨激昂的四分鐘陳詞里，全球主要網(wǎng)站已經(jīng)被黑客入侵了近200次，全球互聯(lián)網(wǎng)計算機可能已經(jīng)被最新病毒感染了170萬臺次……現(xiàn)實中，中學(xué)生上網(wǎng)已帶來了諸多危害：

First, according to a survey, many high school students into small “worm”, indulge in the Internet, will use 90% of the time on online games, made a prisoner of the network, the network of the tired, addicted to the “Internet cafes , ”“ chat rooms ”unable to extricate themselves.Not only delayed learning, and even crime, according to April 2000, “Guangzhou Daily” reported that a 15-year-old high school students to “free” to the Internet to play online games, even killing his own cousin, in order to achieve the purpose of possession of her computer其一，據(jù)一項調(diào)查顯示，不少的中學(xué)生成了小“網(wǎng)蟲”，沉湎于網(wǎng)上，將90%的時間用到網(wǎng)絡(luò)游戲上，做了網(wǎng)絡(luò)的俘虜，為網(wǎng)絡(luò)所累，癡迷于“網(wǎng)吧”、“聊天室”不能自拔。不僅耽誤了學(xué)習(xí)，甚至犯罪，據(jù)2000年4月《廣州日報》報道，一名15歲的中學(xué)生為了“隨心所欲”地上網(wǎng)玩網(wǎng)絡(luò)游戲，竟然殺害自己的表姐，以達到占有她電腦的目的。.Second, students can easily immersed into the virtual network of living space, once back to the real world to produce a sense of loneliness, suffering from “Network alienation syndrome”, singing all day long: the network is my home, I only have eyes it.This caused serious psychological damage.While students are in rapid physical development time, but they are an Internet that is four or five hours, the eyes not only overload, damage eyesight;also makes spinal deformities has really spared no efforts in dying!So the network so much harm to the network in a quick exchange of information, convenience compared to the benefits, do not do more harm than good? Secondly, from the quality on that particular subject we are discussing today is the high school students, they are a special group, they can easily accept new things, very strong desire for knowledge, but they are physical, not psychological maturity, dealing with new things, a lack of ability to distinguish right from wrong, poor self-control.These inherent characteristics of the inherent problems with the network, in essence, constitutes the inherent among online students and irreconcilable contradictions.So reality forced national authorities issued a special law on network management, but the openness, freedom, no features have led to the legal boundaries to be ineffective.As Negroponte pointed out, in the network world, human society, the existing law, if one of the “hard on the deck Badabada breathing fish.” Therefore, in the present and foreseeable future network drawbacks still exist.Perhaps in the future a certain period of a day, the network will become a party to the Pure Land.But a thousand years too long, we seize the day, the reality is that the network has on the students' mental and physical constitute different degrees of damage.Students, faced with our partners from the cast Lo “network” and a “network” Wife, to avoid “network” is a matter of painful, we call the net when the net, cool-cool good time./ / 其二，中學(xué)生極易沉浸到網(wǎng)絡(luò)的虛擬化生活空間中，一旦回到現(xiàn)實社會就產(chǎn)生一種孤獨感，患上“網(wǎng)絡(luò)疏離癥”，成天高唱：網(wǎng)絡(luò)是我家，我的眼里只有它。這樣對心理造成嚴重損害。同時在生理上中學(xué)生正處于快速發(fā)育時間，但是他們一上網(wǎng)就是四、五個小時，不僅眼睛超負荷運轉(zhuǎn)，危害視力；也使得脊椎變形，真可謂鞠躬盡瘁，死而后已！

所以網(wǎng)絡(luò)的這么多弊與網(wǎng)絡(luò)在信息交流方面的快捷性、方便性這一利相比，難道不是弊大于利嗎？

其次，從質(zhì)上說，我們今天討論特定主體是中學(xué)生，他們是特殊的群體，他們易于接受新鮮事物，求知欲望極其強烈，但他們生理、心理還未成熟，對待新事物缺乏辨別是非的能力、自制力差。這些固有的特征，與網(wǎng)絡(luò)固有的問題，在本質(zhì)上就構(gòu)成了中學(xué)生與上網(wǎng)之間固有的不可調(diào)和的矛盾。所以現(xiàn)實迫使國家機關(guān)頒布關(guān)于網(wǎng)絡(luò)管理的專項法律，但網(wǎng)絡(luò)的開放性、自由性、無疆域特征也導(dǎo)致了法律難以奏效。正如尼葛洛龐蒂所指出的，在網(wǎng)絡(luò)世界里，人類社會現(xiàn)存的法律，就好像一條條“在甲板上叭嗒叭嗒拼命喘氣的魚”。所以，在目前及可預(yù)見的將來，網(wǎng)絡(luò)的種種弊端仍然存在。也許將來某年某月某日，網(wǎng)絡(luò)將成為一方凈土。但一萬年太久，我們只爭朝夕，現(xiàn)實是網(wǎng)絡(luò)已經(jīng)對中學(xué)生的身心構(gòu)成了不同程度的傷害。

同學(xué)們，面對我們的伙伴自投羅“網(wǎng)”，而一“網(wǎng)”情深，為避免“網(wǎng)”事不堪回首，我們呼吁該下網(wǎng)時就下網(wǎng)，清清爽爽好時光。// Square two debates: you teachers, students, friends Hello, everyone debates the other side!First of all I would like to argue that the Friends have just heard the other side when committed some mistakes.First of all, the other argued that the United States, 80% of the Friends of the teachers, librarians, after an investigation found that their children can not through the network to improve performance, but I want to ask other friends debate, represent the quality of the results now do? Our country is now implementing quality education, if you just talk about results, it would mean that back to the death of examination-oriented education circles it? Friends give each other all the debate also a special case to prove the shortcomings of the network for our students.However, I want to say anything new in the new phase will always have some drawbacks suited, like the industrial revolution and a variety of feudal relations of production, etc., although a certain amount of time just have a bad influence, but it's great that we can deny it? At present, China is pursuing a policy of quality education in the information age, network and quality education can be said that a person, the reason is that the network can break the boundaries of time and space to reach people at any time, any place, the interaction between the network The advantage of the quality of education greatly helped the quality of education can be said to work onto the wings.As the network of quality education to help, there are now “online distance education,” the term, students can travel through the network around the world famous universities, visit the famous library, check any of the required information can stay at home to participate in academic research , via the Internet from a broad range of subjects to select the appropriate studies, with course materials posted online, comfortably complete their studies, you can immediately know the results after the examination, with questions can e-mail request at any time by instructor.For example, Beijing Normal University High School a few years ago in cooperation with the Beijing Cable and Wireless to launch a Web site View LONDON Beijing Normal University Experimental Middle School, the implementation of synchronous teaching, teaching content all week, Wang Xiao school year by the various disciplines of the experimental weeks of consistent progress, readers across the country through the Internet can be ground to accept a full education.At present, good schools and good teachers are not many, can not fully meet all the studious students thirst for knowledge, the Internet can be restricted to limited space in the original outstanding unlimited expansion of the teaching content, all high school students with Internet access can receive online good first-class secondary school education, so the Internet is particularly important./ /

正方二辯：各位老師、各位同學(xué)、對方辯友大家好！首先我想指出對方辯友在剛才陳詞時犯的一些錯誤。首先，對方辯友說美國有80%的教師、圖書管理員經(jīng)過調(diào)查發(fā)現(xiàn)，他們的孩子不能通過網(wǎng)絡(luò)來提高成績，可是我要問對方辯友，現(xiàn)在成績能代表素質(zhì)嗎？我們國家現(xiàn)在正在推行素質(zhì)教育，如果你們光講成績，那豈不是又回到了應(yīng)試教育的死圈子里嗎？ 還有對方辯友舉出種種的特例來證明網(wǎng)絡(luò)對我們中學(xué)生的弊端。但是，我要說任何新事物在新生階段總會產(chǎn)生一些不適應(yīng)弊端，像工業(yè)革命以及各種封建生產(chǎn)關(guān)系等，雖然在剛產(chǎn)生時造成一定的壞影響，但我們能否定它的偉大嗎？目前我國正在推行素質(zhì)教育的政策，在信息時代里，網(wǎng)絡(luò)與素質(zhì)教育可以說是一家人，其原因是網(wǎng)絡(luò)可以打破時空界限，達到人們在任何時間，任何地點，相互之間的互動交流，網(wǎng)絡(luò)這個優(yōu)勢對素質(zhì)教育幫助極大，可以說是給素質(zhì)教育工作推上了雙翅。由于網(wǎng)絡(luò)對素質(zhì)教育的幫助，目前出現(xiàn)了“網(wǎng)上遠程教育”這個名詞，中學(xué)生可以通過網(wǎng)絡(luò)周游全球各地名牌學(xué)府，訪問著名的圖書館，查詢?nèi)魏嗡栀Y料，足不出戶就可參與學(xué)術(shù)研究，通過互聯(lián)網(wǎng)從廣泛的范圍內(nèi)選擇適當(dāng)科目進行深造，借助在線公布的課程資料，從容地完成學(xué)業(yè)，考試后可以馬上知道成績，有了問題可以隨時通過電子郵件請求老師指導(dǎo)。例如，北師大實驗中學(xué)前幾年就與北京電報局合作在東方網(wǎng)景網(wǎng)站上推出了北師大實驗中學(xué)網(wǎng)校，實行同步教學(xué)，每周網(wǎng)校教學(xué)內(nèi)容全部由實驗中學(xué)年級各學(xué)科各周進度保持一致，讀者在全國各地通過上網(wǎng)都可身臨其境地接受全面教育。目前，我國好學(xué)校和好老師并不多，不能完全滿足所有好學(xué)的學(xué)生對知識的渴求，互聯(lián)網(wǎng)可以把原來限于有限時空里的優(yōu)秀教學(xué)內(nèi)容無限擴大，所有能上網(wǎng)的中學(xué)生都可以在網(wǎng)上接受到全國一流中學(xué)的良好教育，所以上網(wǎng)就顯得尤為重要。// Anti-side two debates: you judge, Students, Hello, everyone!Just the other side argue that the Internet can check the information on the Friends, but the Internet is that students check information? While the other the “Internet” is equivalent to “online education” This is not obvious steal for the proposition it? For many students you chat, search for pornography, for how to explain it? This is the so-called “education” do? Here I will state the students access the system caused by the drawbacks:

反方二辯：各位評委、各位同學(xué)，大家好！剛才對方辯友說上網(wǎng)可以查資料，但是中學(xué)生上網(wǎng)就是查資料嗎？同時對方把“上網(wǎng)”等同于“網(wǎng)上教育”這不明擺著偷換命題嗎？那么你對許多中學(xué)生網(wǎng)上聊天、搜尋色情信息，作如何解釋呢？這就是所謂的“教育”嗎？ 下面我將系統(tǒng)地陳述中學(xué)生上網(wǎng)所造成的種種弊端：

First, the online information varies greatly, often fragmented and not Internet access to those systems of knowledge, not only will not improve the ability of students, rather than in the past degradation, but there are many high school students, because they can not handle too much information and suffering “ information anxiety ”and other mental illness.In addition, according to Britain's Tim Laibei Middlesex University Professor of Statistics, online information, 47% of non-learning related to violence and pornography, once the students are exposed to this information, what the consequences would be disastrous.第一、網(wǎng)上的信息良莠不齊，經(jīng)常上網(wǎng)獲取那些零散和不系統(tǒng)的知識，不但不會提高中學(xué)生的能力，反而會比以往退化，而且還有不少中學(xué)生，因為無法處理過量的信息而患上“信息焦慮”等精神病。此外，據(jù)英國的米德塞克斯大學(xué)的蒂姆萊貝教授統(tǒng)計，網(wǎng)上非學(xué)習(xí)信息有47%與色情暴力有關(guān)，一旦學(xué)生接觸到這些信息，那后果將不堪設(shè)想。

Second, the network has infinite attraction for students, thus resulting in a large part of the students indulge in the network, thus suffering from “Internet addiction disorder”, “network alienation syndrome” and other new types of mental illness, family members do not these students do not Wangchong Men , detached from real life, is entirely a bunch of robots programmed thinking class.第二、由于網(wǎng)絡(luò)對中學(xué)生具有無限吸引力，所以導(dǎo)致很大一部分中學(xué)生沉溺于網(wǎng)絡(luò)，從而患上“網(wǎng)絡(luò)上癮癥”、“網(wǎng)絡(luò)疏離癥”等新型的精神性疾病，這些網(wǎng)蟲們不要家人不要同學(xué)，脫離現(xiàn)實生活，完全是一群有著程序化思維的類機器人。

Third, the network communication induced secondary life and values conflict, mostly because online dissemination of information is the main Western countries, which are often high school students with access to the information the brain accumulation of an impact on Chinese culture, will form a serious Another colonialism.第三、網(wǎng)絡(luò)傳播誘發(fā)中學(xué)生人生觀、價值觀的沖突，由于網(wǎng)上傳播的大多是以西方發(fā)達國家的信息為主，這往往與接觸這些信息的中學(xué)生腦中積淀的中國文化產(chǎn)生沖擊，嚴重的會形成另一種殖民主義。

Fourth, the extensive use of language weakening the network of national and cultural qualities of students.Network usage and content in English as most were 84% and 90%, online typos, wrong sentences everywhere, students and long-term environmental exposure to this language, can not help worrying.Finally, I remind the other side argue the fact that a large number of friends do not turn a deaf ear./ / 第四、網(wǎng)絡(luò)語言的大量使用弱化中學(xué)生的民族文化素質(zhì)。網(wǎng)絡(luò)上以英語的使用率和內(nèi)容為最多，分別為84%和90%，網(wǎng)上的錯別字、病句隨處可見，中學(xué)生長期與這種語言環(huán)境接觸，不能不令人擔(dān)憂。

最后，我提醒對方辯友不要對大量事實聽而不聞。// Chairman: We can see just the standard speech, both debaters can say with confidence, determined to win.Please enter the following we will test the ability of individuals to be cross-examination debate stage, let us taste of what the debater's edge and sharp intellectual.In addition to the anti-side three limited debate time, other players are used when one minute, ask the questions the anti-side three debates, the time is 20 seconds./ / 主席：大家可以看到在剛才的規(guī)范發(fā)言中，雙方辯手可以說是胸有成竹，志在必得。請接下來我們將進入考驗個人應(yīng)辯能力的盤問階段，請大家領(lǐng)略一下辯手的鋒芒與銳智。除反方三辯的時間有限制外，其他隊員用時均為1分鐘，先請反方三辯提問，時間為20秒。// Cross-examination stage / /盤問階段 // Anti-side three debates: just the other side argue Friends of the cited examples of our school site, but there are a number of information High School Wang Xiao garbage, which is recently pointed out two generations of leaders will be Lieutenant Colonel.Now I ask other friends argue, how to resolve the nature of poor students made three major network problem? / / 反方三辯：剛才對方辯友舉了我校網(wǎng)站的例子，可是附中網(wǎng)校里有許多信息垃圾，這也是前不久兩代會中校領(lǐng)導(dǎo)指出的?，F(xiàn)在我請問對方辯友，如何解決中學(xué)生自制性差的天性與網(wǎng)絡(luò)的三大問題呢？ // Square three debates: Please note that other friends argue that any new thing in the beginning part of it is essential to bring some drawbacks, but we must see these things in their development prospects and the general trend, then I ask you the other side argue Friends admit that in the information age is an important tool for the network, please direct answer yes or no.Thank you!/ /

正方三辯：請對方辯友注意，任何新生事物在它開始階段部分都必不可少帶來一些弊端，但我們必須看到這些事物它們發(fā)展的前景和總的趨勢，那我請問對方辯友你是否承認在信息時代網(wǎng)絡(luò)是一種重要的工具請正面回答是或不是。謝謝！// Anti-side of a debate: argue the other side may not hear clearly just friends, in a debate, I have heard that the network is an important means of communication, but also pointed out that the three major network problem, which illustrates the disadvantages of the Italian students online, do the other Friends do not understand the debate? What other defense friends, this online virtual space, the interaction between people is often with a mask, which is water, Jing Zhonghua What is the difference? Please direct answer!/ /

反方一辯：對方辯友剛才或許沒聽清楚，在一辯陳詞中我已指出網(wǎng)絡(luò)是一種重要的通訊手段，還指出網(wǎng)絡(luò)的三大問題，這就說明了中學(xué)生上網(wǎng)弊大利，難道對方辯友沒有理解嗎？請問對方辯友，在網(wǎng)上這種虛擬空間中，人與人之間的交往往往帶著一個假面具，這與水中月、鏡中花有什么區(qū)別？請正面回答！// Square one debate: online communication is really no sense in it? How so many people that use it? What other defense friends, more harm than good if the students online, then how will access the national curriculum to the computer courses come from? / / 正方一辯：在網(wǎng)上交往真的沒意義了嗎？那怎么會有那么多人上網(wǎng)呢？請問對方辯友，如果中學(xué)生上網(wǎng)是弊大于利的話，那么國家怎么會把上網(wǎng)這個課程安排到計算機課程中來呢？ // Anti-side two debates: I would like to point out that the current national curriculum does not put the Internet to a computer program, there are debates if you really like each other friends said, then why the state should enact legislation to ban high school students to enter the underground cafe it? Friends then ask the other debate, in both advantages and disadvantages of online students in the case, how do you judge the more good than harm it? / /

反方二辯：我想首先指出，目前國家并沒有把上網(wǎng)課程安排到計算機課程中，還有如果真像對方辯友所說的話，那么國家為什么要制定法律禁止中學(xué)生進入地下網(wǎng)吧呢？再請教對方辯友，在中學(xué)生上網(wǎng)利和弊兼有的情況下，你是如何判斷利大于弊呢？ // Square two debate: I think Lee is the mainstream, disadvantages arise only in the network just some inevitable drawbacks, just a debate three debates have repeatedly stressed, we can see the other side argue friends do not understand.Will the other three debates, practical and computer access as a course need to apply their knowledge, whether or not to access the knowledge into practice? / /正方二辯：我認為利是主流，弊只是在網(wǎng)絡(luò)剛剛產(chǎn)生時不可避免的出現(xiàn)一些弊端，剛才的一辯三辯已經(jīng)反復(fù)強調(diào)，可見了對方辯友沒有理解。請問對方三辯，學(xué)以致用，電腦上網(wǎng)作為一門課程是否需要學(xué)以致用，是否要把上網(wǎng)知識付諸于實踐？ //

Anti-side three debates: to put into practice, but we are talking about the Internet does not mean all people.Our premise is to high school students, high school students is a sense of nature and the relatively poor self-control, on-line information that they can properly handle the waste it? Friends just can not answer each other's debate the pros and cons to determine the size of the standard, I tell you, first of all we have to judge from the number, the three major problems with its network of convenience and quickness are three disadvantages compared to a benefit, do not argue the other Friends also say big profits to harm it? Secondly, from the quality of said high school students self-control, sense of weakness and poor nature of the three major networks is inherently irreconcilable

contradiction.Thus

our re-emphasized, students access more harm than good.Thank you!/ /

反方三辯：是要付諸實踐，但我們所說的上網(wǎng)并不是指所有的人。我們的前提是中學(xué)生，中學(xué)生的天性是判斷力和自制力比較差，對網(wǎng)上的信息垃圾它們能夠正確處理嗎？剛才對方辯友無法回答判斷利弊大小標(biāo)準(zhǔn)，我現(xiàn)在告訴大家，首先我們從數(shù)量上判斷，網(wǎng)絡(luò)三大問題與其方便性和快捷性相比是三弊一利，難道對方辯友還要說利大于弊嗎？其次，從質(zhì)上說，中學(xué)生自制力、判斷力差的天性弱點與網(wǎng)絡(luò)三大問題是不可調(diào)和的固有矛盾。所以我方再次強調(diào)，中學(xué)生上網(wǎng)弊大于利。謝謝！//

Chairman: Thank you debater, just free debate, but the tip-to-head.Now let's hear both sides debate how to sum up the four submissions./ / 主席：謝謝各位辯手，剛才的自由辯論，可是針尖對麥芒。接下來我們來聽聽雙方四辯是如何來總結(jié)陳詞的。// Wind up the anti-side four debates: Thank you!You judges, teachers, students Hello, everyone!Today, the other a great deal of debate set out examples of friends, students at all exaggerated to say how good the Internet, how good!Students can bring a series of drawbacks understatement Internet, and even wiped gently like a spider web!This does not respect the fact that wood for the trees or the blinders of attitude is really not a compliment!At the same time, the subject of today's debate-the characteristics of high school students can not really explain it herself, to know who you knew of it!The more critical is the other side of this today, “the pros and cons” comparison of the size of a standard has not, then your argument come from? Today, we have the spirit of their own as students, to pursue their healthy growth with each other to explore this topic is full of subjective perceived.Whether it is a big profit disadvantages or just harm the Italian, what we do is not the ultimate goal while avoiding disadvantages it? Recognize the seriousness of the problem, then try to solve the problem is our position today, the fundamental starting point.Here I am Once again I summarize our point of view: 反方四辯總結(jié)陳詞：謝謝主席！各位評委、老師、同學(xué)們大家好！

今天，對方辯友羅列了大量的例子，不惜夸大其詞地說中學(xué)生上網(wǎng)如何好，如何好！可對中學(xué)生上網(wǎng)帶來的一系列弊端輕描淡寫，甚至像蜘蛛網(wǎng)一樣輕輕的抹去！這種不尊重事實，只見樹木不見森林或者說一葉障目的態(tài)度，的確無法令人恭維！同時，對今天辯論的主體--中學(xué)生的特征也說不出個所以然來，要知道人貴自知之呀！而更為關(guān)鍵的是今天對方對這個“利弊”大小的比較始終沒有一個標(biāo)準(zhǔn)，那你們的立論從何而來呢？

今天，我們本著對自己作為中學(xué)生，對自己健康成長的追求來同對方一起探討這個充滿主觀意想的話題。無論是利大弊也好，還是弊大利也好，我們的最終目的難道不是趨利避害嗎？認識到問題的嚴重性，進而設(shè)法解決問題是我方今天立場的根本出發(fā)點。下面我再一次我總結(jié)我方觀點： First, only recognized the current network of three major issues, we can make the network become a party to pursue the Pure Land.Legal sanctions, helpless, pale technical limitations of the ethics behind all so worried about the inner insight and anxiety.Look at the underground cafe, look at those high school students visit the web interface, the true? Quot;sex and trash flying, false of violence the same color.“None of the facts tell us that students do not control the Internet, then, how to make the community believe that we the motherland better future?

第一、只有認識到目前網(wǎng)絡(luò)的三大問題，我們才能去追求讓網(wǎng)絡(luò)成為一方凈土。法律制裁的無奈、道德規(guī)范的蒼白技術(shù)限制的落后無不令有識之士的內(nèi)心感到憂慮和不安?？纯茨切┑叵戮W(wǎng)吧，看看那些中學(xué)生瀏覽的網(wǎng)頁界面，真可?quot;色情與垃圾齊飛，虛假共暴力一色”。樁樁事實告訴我們，中學(xué)生上網(wǎng)不加以控制的話，怎么讓社會相信我們是祖國美好的未來呢？

Second, only recognize the special group is a group of students to face the reality and problems, we never expect each student to become the Internet's foresight and Sage, sage, and from discipline to discipline is a long and tortuous process , only the omnipotent “God” that may send numerous “angel” down to earth students for each Internet, said: “Hey, man, this thing Evil.” But the fact also tells us that students are often out of curiosity or impulse, deliberately go looking for some sex, to information and thus lead to social problems such as sexual crimes.Guess the other Friends of God debate at this moment think? He would only say: “Sorry!Not my s the heart, but I am helpless.”

第二、只有認識到中學(xué)生是一群特殊的群體，才能正視現(xiàn)實和問題，我們從不奢望每個上網(wǎng)的中學(xué)生會成為先知先覺和賢者、圣人，而從他律走向自律是一個漫長曲折的過程，只有萬能的“上帝”才可能派出無數(shù)的“天使”下凡對每個上網(wǎng)的中學(xué)生說：“嘿，伙計，此物非禮勿視?！笨墒聦嵱指嬖V我們中學(xué)生往往會出于好奇或沖動，刻意去尋找一些色情，努力信息進而引發(fā)諸如性犯罪等社會問題。此時此刻對方辯友猜猜上帝會怎么想？他只會說：“Sorry！不是我的心太軟，只是我很無奈。” Third, only recognize the disadvantages of the Italian students online, in order to mobilize various forces in society and a variety of means to avoid weaknesses, while avoiding disadvantages.We are the May flowers, but flowers, pests have been eroded, only to get rid of the shackles of the network to use their youth to embrace the times, we are the rising sun, but there were dark clouds kept the sun, when worn, and only when the lower network the net in order to ignite the next with his life!“Castle not cover the river from flowing eastward.” We have a dream: a morning in the new century, and when I do rob wave dimensions of the human spirit to last glance cast at home, we face the majority of students are new to the new state, new challenges!Thank you!只有認識到中學(xué)生上網(wǎng)弊大利，才能調(diào)動社會的各方面力量和各種手段來揚長避短、趨利避害。我們是五月的花朵，但花朵有被害蟲侵蝕的時候，只有擺脫網(wǎng)絡(luò)的束縛才能用青春擁抱時代，我們是初升的太陽，但太陽也有被烏云蒙敝的時候，只有該下網(wǎng)時就下網(wǎng)，才能用生命點燃未來！“青山遮不住，畢竟東流去”。我們有一個夢想：在新世紀的一個清晨，當(dāng)我向度盡劫波的人類精神家園投去最后一瞥時，我們廣大中學(xué)生正以新面貌新狀態(tài)，迎接新挑戰(zhàn)！謝謝！// Square four wind up debate: Thank you!Friends argue the other side, teachers, students Hello, everyone!First, I want to do some analysis for the other argument.Admittedly, the other argument wonderful wisdom, but the truth is not a modification is made, the other argument of the vulnerability is still clearly visible: just the other side argue that part of the Friends of the students use the Internet to visit sites of some unhealthy or criminal acts.But this really true? I might make some bold assumptions.If there is no network, those who lack self-control of a number of high school students do not read books or engage in other unhealthy crime? So I think this is a mentality problem and not the network nature of the problem.Secondly, I want to do for the motion, the following analysis: 謝謝主席！對方辯友、老師、同學(xué)大家好！首先，我想針對對方辯詞做一些分析。不可否認，對方辯詞精彩睿智，但真理不是修飾而成的，對方辯詞中的漏洞依舊清晰可見：剛才對方辯友指出一部分學(xué)生上網(wǎng)是為了瀏覽一些不健康網(wǎng)站或進行犯罪行為。但事實果真如此嗎？我不妨作些大膽假設(shè)。如果沒有網(wǎng)絡(luò)，那些缺乏自制能力的中學(xué)生難道不會閱讀一些不健康的書籍或從事其他犯罪嗎？所以我認為這是一個心態(tài)問題而不是網(wǎng)絡(luò)本質(zhì)問題。其次，我想針對此次辯題做如下分析：

First, on high school students, 13-19 years of age is in school.This population has the following characteristics: ① destined for their age they will become tomorrow's builders, responsible for the hold up on their shoulders the important task of the future.Their task is to keep up the pace.Grasp of science and technology;② age of high school students new to both of them curious about the lack of self-control;③ Therefore, they can not live without teachers, parents and the leadership of the world wherever and whenever they are from the community, schools and family protection.一、關(guān)于中學(xué)生，是指13-19周歲在校學(xué)生。這類人群有以下特點：①他們年齡注定他們將成為明天的建設(shè)者，他們肩上擔(dān)負的是托起未來的重任。他們的任務(wù)是跟上時代的腳步。及時掌握科學(xué)技術(shù)；②中學(xué)生的年齡也使他們對新生事物既充滿好奇，又缺乏自制力；③因此，他們的生活離不開老師、家長的領(lǐng)導(dǎo)，他們的世界時時處處受到來自社會、學(xué)校、家庭的保護。Second, on the Internet.What is a network? Information processing network is born to be a set of pregnant learning, communication and entertainment tool for the appropriate time to relax.And it is not a common tool, it has other things are irreplaceable advantages: 1, can break the boundaries of time and space, so no matter when and where people can communicate with each other, make information processing more systematic and comprehensive;2, so that the flow of information more timely, convenient, so the educational choices of the Internet, the world has chosen the Internet.This is an era of rapid development of science and technology, competition, talent competition to become the mainstream of the world, in the face of education in the long-awaited reform.The advent, education reform will undoubtedly become a good helper.This colorful face of network space, we can easily free to listen to teacher lectures, you can swim immersive wonderful space, no longer limited to books, we learn, we have the scientific quality gradually.集學(xué)習(xí)、通訊及適當(dāng)時候放松的娛樂工具。而它又不是一種普通的工具，它有著其他事物所不可替代的優(yōu)勢：

1、可以打破時空界限，使人們無論在何時何地都能進行相互交流，可使信息處理更系統(tǒng)，全面；

2、使信息流通更及時、便捷，所以教育選擇了上網(wǎng)，世界選擇上網(wǎng)。這是一個科技高速發(fā)展的時代，人才競爭成為世界競爭的主流，教育在千呼萬喚中面臨改革。而網(wǎng)絡(luò)的出現(xiàn)，無疑成了教育改革的好幫手。面對網(wǎng)絡(luò)這個五彩繽紛的空間，我們可以輕松自由地聽名師講座，可以身臨其境地暢游奇妙太空，我們學(xué)習(xí)不再僅限于書本，我們也逐漸擁有了科學(xué)素質(zhì)。

Of course, do not deny our network plagued by problems.Because no new thing are pros and cons, but as evidenced by the Friends of our debate, if it is more widely exposed to the positive side of things, how can we say it is more harm than good? It's like fish, we sometimes fish bone stuck in his throat, but we can only say that because a few bones to eat? Quot;more harm than good “do? Not because the fish bone stuck throat only occasionally, if you are careful, security can be avoided;but as long as we fish, we will be able to get nutrition.students access the same;so we have every reason, have the confidence to say: students online more good than harm!Thank you!

當(dāng)然，我方也不否認網(wǎng)絡(luò)存在弊端。因為任何一個新生事物都有利有弊，但正如我方辯友所證明的，如果人們更廣泛接觸到的是事物有利的一面，我們又怎能說是弊大于利呢？這就像吃魚一樣，我們有時會被魚刺卡住喉嚨，但我們能僅因為這幾根骨頭就說吃?quot;弊大于利”嗎？不行。因為魚刺卡喉嚨只是偶爾，如果小心，安全可以避免；但只要我們吃魚，就一定能得到營養(yǎng)。中學(xué)生上網(wǎng)也一樣；所以我們完全有理由，也有信心地說：中學(xué)生上網(wǎng)利大于弊！謝謝！

第五篇：講誠信辯論會總結(jié)

辯論會的主題：“講誠信”與“善意的謊言”

正方觀點：人要講誠信，不能說謊

反方觀點：生活需要善意的謊言

誠信與謊言，是兩個完全相反的概念，也是兩種相對立的道德行為的表現(xiàn)。講誠信，自古以來被人們稱為做人立國的根本，是做人最美好的品格；謊言，從來都是與陰暗、卑微的形象相聯(lián)系。但是，本周我們學(xué)習(xí)了《別餓壞了那匹馬》、《用心靈去傾聽》之后，我們似乎對謊言有了新的認識。今天，我們在開班會時，就“講誠信”與“善意的謊言”展開了辯論。

在大家熱烈的掌聲中，辯論會開始。正反雙方的主辨手，表明了各方的觀點。雙方陣容都很強勢，正方主辯李昊哲，是我們班最強勢的“巧嘴八哥”，他胸有成竹地首當(dāng)其沖，用實例闡述了“講誠信”，是做人應(yīng)該具備的最基本的品德；“講誠信”也是人與人之間“關(guān)系”的牢固性，朋友之間的友誼是否能長久最堅實的基礎(chǔ)。他們有理有據(jù)的發(fā)言，博得了同學(xué)們的熱情贊揚。

反方主辯喬啟源，不僅口才好得不得了，心理素質(zhì)也極強。只見他面對正反的初戰(zhàn)告捷，依然是不驚不慌、鎮(zhèn)定自若，他以自己生活中的實例，維護自己一方的觀點。“我方不否認你們觀點的正確性，但是你們忽略了現(xiàn)實生活中特殊情況的存在?！彼{(diào)整了一下情緒，滿懷深情地繼續(xù)說：“前年，我的奶奶被確診為喉癌。爸爸媽媽怕老人知道后，接受不了現(xiàn)實，精神上再受嚴重的打擊加重病情，就隱瞞了真實病情。媽媽告訴奶奶只是嗓子炎癥比較嚴重而已。我們?nèi)覈朗剡@個秘密，用善意的謊言，“欺騙”了老人。奶奶以為自己就是一般的病，減輕了精神壓力，消除了嚴重的心理負擔(dān)，并且積極配合治療，病情得到很好的控制······”

“假如，我們這時講誠信，不計后果地把真實的病情告訴我的奶奶，那么，讓我的奶奶背負著沉重的思想包袱，抱著自己的病無醫(yī)可治、必死無疑的心態(tài)，其后果會是什么樣呢？”他思路清晰有理有據(jù)，又運用了反問的方式，駁回了正方不就事論事，也就是太絕對的觀點。

雙方成員個個都是精兵強將，都有著能說會辯的伶牙俐齒，你說一言，我就對一語，雙方各執(zhí)一詞激烈的爭辯著。那陣勢好似針尖對麥芒，互不相讓。辯論會在激烈的爭辯中，把大家的情緒帶動得極其高漲。辯手們的提問聲、回答聲、反問聲、辯論聲，加上同學(xué)們熱烈的歡呼聲、喝彩聲和鼓勵的掌聲，眾聲音匯集在一起，是聲聲有力，聲聲入耳。大家都以積極的態(tài)度，全身心地融入到了其中。

一時間，辯論會似乎很難分出勝負。因為，雙方各有各的說法，各有各的道理。所以，我想即使是最后有了勝負的結(jié)果，也只是語言上的勝利而已。因為他們各自都有難以推翻的、堅實的實例，充分地證明著自己所支持的觀點。辯論到最終，以正方勝的結(jié)果，結(jié)束了這場激烈的辯論。

最后，老師比較全面地給我們做了總結(jié)。老師聲音柔和、態(tài)度和藹地告訴我們：

“‘民無信不立’，誠信自古以來，就是中華民族的傳統(tǒng)美德。誠信之人會擁有更多的朋友，做事情也更容易成功。但是有的時候，善意的謊言也會如一股暖流，一陣春風(fēng)，能幫人接觸暫時的痛苦。同學(xué)們要分清‘講誠信’與‘善意的謊言’兩者之間的關(guān)系，以誠信為本，即使是善意，謊言也盡量少用，要掌握尺度，以免走向虛偽的一端?！?/p>

老師的總結(jié)，也就是我們舉辦這次班級辯論會，期望達到的最完美的結(jié)果。通過這次成功的辯論會，大家經(jīng)歷了辯論會的整個過程，既長了見識，又牢固地掌握了本單元所學(xué)的知識。更使我們懂得了“講誠信”和“善意的謊言”，兩者的概念和它們之間的關(guān)系。也明白了做人要以講誠信為本，做一個有道德、講誠信的人。

我們要時刻告誡自己，在生活中盡量避免撒謊，就是在不得已的情況下，說了“善意的謊言”，但是一定要把握好尺度。切不可把“善意的謊言”使用的“過”了，歪曲了其“善”的本意，失去了運用“善意的謊言”的意義。那么，其結(jié)果就偏離了“善意”的軌道。